All Posts in

September 4, 2024 - Comments Off on درخواستوں کے لئے اعلان

درخواستوں کے لئے اعلان

 دیہی میڈیا سپورٹ پروگرام

کیا آپ بلوچستان، خیبر پختونخوا، سندھ، یا جنوبی پنجاب میں قائم ایک آزاد میڈیا آؤٹ لیٹ ہیں؟ ہم آپ کو ایک منفرد دو سالہ پروگرام کے لیے درخواست دینے کی دعوت دیتے ہیں جو آپ کی تنظیم کی صلاحیتوں کو مضبوط کرے گا، آپ کے مواد کی پیداوار کو بہتر بنائے گا، اور دیگر دیہی میڈیا اداروں کے ساتھ مشترکہ وکالت اور تعاون کو فروغ دے گا۔

پروگرام کے فوائد:

اس پروگرام میں شرکت کے ذریعے، میڈیا آؤٹ لیٹس یہ مواقع حاصل کریں گے:

اپنی داخلی صلاحیتوں کو مضبوط بنائیں تاکہ وہ زیادہ محفوظ، جامع، اور بہتر انداز سے کام کر سکیں۔ --

 مواد کی پیداوار کی مہارتوں کو بہتر بنائیں اور میڈیا میں دیہی آوازوں کی نمائندگی کو فروغ دیں۔ --

دیگر دیہی آزاد میڈیا اداروں کے ساتھ روابط قائم کریں تاکہ علاقائی سطح پر سیکھنے اور مشترکہ وکالت کے --
مواقع سے فائدہ اٹھا سکیں۔

پروگرام کی ساخت:

یہ پروگرام اکتوبر 2024 سے اکتوبر 2026 تک چلے گا اور اس میں درج ذیل اجزاء شامل ہوں گے:

 ۱- تربیتی سیشنز

پورے پروگرام کے دوران، منتخب میڈیا آؤٹ لیٹس تربیتی سیشنز کی ایک سیریز میں حصہ لیں گے جو درج ذیل شعبوں میں اپنی داخلی صلاحیتوں کو مضبوط کرنے کے لیے ڈیزائن کیا گیا ہے:

جنس اور اسکی بہتر شمولیت --
(ڈیجیٹل) حفاظت --
اندرونی حکمرانی اور تنظیمی طریقہ کار --
ناظرین/ قارئین کی مشغولیت --
متبادل پروڈکشن ماڈل اور SWOT تجزیہ --

ماہرین کی ایک ٹیم کی قیادت میں تربیتی سیشنز ہر منتخب ساتھی ادارے کی مخصوص ضروریات کو پورا کرنے کے لیے تیار کیے جائیں گے۔ یہ تربیتی نشستیں ایک مخلوط طرز میں منعقد کی جائیں گی، آن لائن اور آن سائٹ بات چیت کو ملایا جائے گا۔ براہ راست سیشنز کے دوران، شرکاء کو پہلے سے طے شدہ اہداف کی طرف اپنی پیشرفت کا باقاعدگی سے جائزہ لینے، تفویض کے نتائج کا جائزہ لینے اور ماہر ٹیم سے رہنمائی حاصل کرنے کا موقع ملے گا۔

۲ -فیلو شپس:

منتخب شدہ میڈیا ادارے اور ان کے متعلقہ (فری لانس) صحافی بھی چھ ماہ کی چار دورانیے والی فیلوشپ میں شرکت کریں گے جو مواد کی پیداوار کی مہارتوں کو بڑھانے اور پاکستانی میڈیا میں دیہی آوازوں کی نمائندگی کو بڑھانے کے لیے تیار کی گئی ہیں۔

منتخب میڈیا ادارے ماہرین کی طرف سے فراہم کردہ تربیتی ورکشاپس کی ایک سیریز کے ذریعے اپنی مواد کی تیاری کی مہارت کو بہترکریں گے۔ یہ مندرجہ ذیل موضوعات پر توجہ مرکوز کریں گے:

ڈیجیٹل کہانی سنانے، سامعین کی مشغولیت، اور متبادل پیداوار/کاروباری ماڈل، بشمول مصنوعی ذہانت (AI) کا استعمال --

اخلاقی صحافت، حقائق کی جانچ، اور جھوٹی/غلط معلومات کی تصدیق اور تردید --

جامع رپورٹنگ --

اس کے علاوہ، فیلوشپ کے شرکاء کو ایسے مواد کی تیاری میں ماہرین کی مدد حاصل ہوگی جو پاکستان میں دیہی کمیونٹی، خواتین، اور پسماندہ گروہ کی آوازوں کو اجاگر کرے، اور میڈیا کے زیادہ جامع اور متنوع منظرنامے میں حصہ ڈالتا ہے۔

۳-حمایتی اقدامات

منتخب شدہ میڈیا اداروں کو ایک مخصوص نیٹ ورک کے ذریعے دیگر دیہی میڈیا اداروں کے ساتھ بات چیت، تبادلہ خیال، اور رابطہ قائم کرنے کا موقع بھی ملے گا۔ اس اقدام کے تحت، تین اتحاد سازی ورکشاپس کا انعقاد کیا جائے گا تاکہ باہمی تعاون کو فروغ دیا جا سکے اور درج ذیل موضوعاتی چیلنجز پر مشترکہ حمایتی اقدامات کو تحریک دی جا سکے:

آزادی صحافت اور صحافیوں کی جسمانی حفاظت --
میڈیا کے شعبے میں صنف، تنوع اور شمولیت --
میڈیا پر ابھرتی ہوئی ٹیکنالوجیز کا اثر --
مالی استحکام --

ان اتحاد سازی ورکشاپس کے دوران، منتخب شدہ ادارے ہر موضوعاتی چیلنج کے لیے مخصوص اہداف مقرر کریں گے اور ان کو پورا کرنے کے لیے عمل کے منصوبے تیار کریں گے جو پروگرام کے دوران نافذ کیے جائیں گے۔

درخواست کا طریقہ کار

کون درخواست دے سکتا ہے؟

ہم میڈیا آؤٹ لیٹس کی درخواستوں کا خیرمقدم کرتے ہیں جو درج ذیل اہلیت کے معیار پر پورا اترتی ہیں:

بلوچستان، خیبر پختونخواہ ، سندھ، یا جنوبی پنجاب میں واقع ہے۔ --
کم از کم 1 سال سے آپریشنل --
مالی اور ادارتی طور پر آزاد --
صنفی مساوات اور شمولیت کے لیے پرعزم --
مفاد عامہ کی صحافت میں فعال طور پر مصروف --
معقول صلاحیت، حالیہ سرگرمی، اور زمین پر موجودگی ثابت کرنے کے قابل --

درخواست جمع کروانے کا طریقہ

اپنی پسند کی زبان میں درخواست فارم ڈاؤن لوڈ کریں:

انگریزی میں درخواست فارم --

اردو میں درخواست فارم --

براہ کرم درخواست فارم کے تمام حصوں کو پُر کریں، اس بات کو یقینی بناتے ہوئے کہ فراہم کردہ تمام معلومات درست اور تازہ ترین ہیں۔

مکمل کرنے کے بعد، اپنی درخواست کو [ruralmediasupport@protonmail.com ] پر ای میل کے ذریعے بھیجیں، اور موضوع کے لائن میں درج ذیل لکھیں: “دیہی میڈیا سپورٹ پروگرام کے لیے درخواست - [آپ کے ادارے کا نام اور صوبہ]”

براہ کرم نوٹ کریں کہ آپ کو انگریزی یا اردو میں صرف ایک درخواست فارم جمع کرنا ہوگا، اور مختلف ٹیمپلیٹس یا فارمیٹس کا استعمال کرتے ہوئے جمع کرائی گئی درخواستیں قبول نہیں کی جائیں گی۔

جمع کرانے کی آخری تاریخ 15 ستمبر 2024 ہے۔ براہ کرم نوٹ کریں کہ صرف آخری تاریخ تک بھیجی گئی مکمل درخواستوں پر ہی غور کیا جائے گا۔

منتخب کرنے کا طریقہ کار

درخواستوں کا جائزہ سلیکشن کمیٹی کے ذریعہ درج ذیل انتخابی معیار کی بنیاد پر کیا جائے گا:

مالی اور ادارتی آزادی --
صنف کو مرکزی دھارے میں لانے اور شمولیت کے لیے عزم ظاہر کیا۔ --
مفاد عامہ کی صحافت میں فعال مشغولیت --
دو سالہ پروگرام میں شرکت کا عزم --
ترقی کی صلاحیت --
مشغول سامعین --

انتخابی کمیٹی تمام جمع کردہ درخواستوں کا تفصیلی جائزہ لے گی اور ایسے میڈیا اداروں کی شارٹ لسٹ تیار کرے گی جو پروگرام کے لیے سب سے زیادہ موزوں سمجھے جائیں، درخواست فارم میں فراہم کردہ معلومات کی بنیاد پر۔ شارٹ لسٹ کیے گئے امیدواروں کوحتمی منتخب کردہ آؤٹ لیٹ کے عمل کے حصے کے طور پر انٹرویو میں شرکت کی دعوت دی جائے گی۔

درخواست دہندگان کو درخواستوں کی وصولی کی مدت کے اختتام کے بعد زیادہ سے زیادہ 1 ماہ کے اندر ان کی درخواست کی حتمی حیثیت کے بارے میں مطلع کیا جائے گا۔

مالی معاونت

براہ کرم نوٹ کریں کہ پروگرام کی پوری مدت کے دوران شرکاء کے ٹرانسپورٹ اورٹھہرنے کے اخراجات منتظمین برداشت کریں گے۔

کسی بھی سوالات یا مزید معلومات کے لیے، براہ کرم رابطہ کریں [ruralmediasupport@protonmail.com ]

September 4, 2024 - Comments Off on CALL FOR APPLICATIONS

CALL FOR APPLICATIONS

Rural Media Support Programme


Are you an independent media outlet based in Balochistan, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Sindh, or South Punjab? We invite you to apply for a unique two-year programme designed to strengthen your internal capacities, enhance your content production, and foster joint advocacy and collaboration with fellow rural media outlets. 

Programme Benefits

By participating in this programme, media outlets will be able to:

  1. Strengthen their internal capacities in order to operate in a safer, more inclusive, and resilient manner
  2. Elevate their content production skills and amplify the representation of rural voices in media
  3. Connect with fellow independent rural media outlets for cross-regional learning and advocacy

Programme Structure

The programme will run from October 2024 to October 2026 and will include the following components:

1. Coaching Sessions

Throughout the programme, selected media outlets will participate in a series of coaching sessions designed to strengthen their internal capacities in the following areas:

  • Gender and inclusion
  • (Digital) safety
  • Internal governance and organizational procedures
  • Audience engagement
  • Alternative production models and SWOT analyses

The coaching sessions, led by a team of experts, will be tailored to meet the specific needs of each outlet. These sessions will be conducted in a hybrid format, blending online and on-site interactions. During one-on-one sessions, participants will have the opportunity to regularly assess their progress toward predefined goals, review assignment outcomes, and seek guidance from the expert team.

2. Fellowships

Selected media outlets and their respective pools of (freelance) journalists will also participate in four rounds of six-month fellowships designed to enhance content production skills and amplify rural voices in Pakistani media.

Media outlets will elevate their content production skills through a series of workshops facilitated by experts. These will focus on the following topics:

  • Digital storytelling, audience engagement, and alternative production/business models, including the use of Artificial Intelligence (AI)
  • Ethical journalism, fact-checking, and pre/debunking mis/disinformation
  • Inclusive reporting

Additionally, fellowship participants will receive expert support in producing content that amplifies the voices of rural communities, women, and marginalized groups in Pakistan, contributing to a more inclusive and diverse media landscape.

3. Advocacy

Selected media outlets will also have the opportunity to engage, exchange, and connect with fellow rural media outlets through the creation of a dedicated network. As part of this initiative, three coalition-building workshops will be organized to foster collaboration and stimulate joint advocacy on the following thematic challenges: 

  • Press freedom and journalists’ physical safety 
  • Gender, diversity, and inclusion in the media sector
  • The influence of emerging technologies on media
  • Financial sustainability

During these coalition-building workshops, the selected outlets will set specific goals for each thematic challenge and develop action plans to achieve them over the course of the programme. 

Application Procedure

Who can apply?

We welcome applications from media outlets that meet the following eligibility criteria: 

  • Located in Balochistan, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Sindh or South Punjab
  • Operational for at least 1 year
  • Financially and editorially independent 
  • Committed to gender equality and inclusion
  • Actively engaged in public interest journalism
  • Able to prove reasonable capacity, recent activity, and on-the ground presence

How to apply

  1. Download the Application Form in your preferred language:
  1. Please fill out all sections of the Application Form, ensuring that all information provided is accurate and up to date.
  2. Once completed, send your application by email to ruralmediasupport@protonmail.com, using the following subject line: “Application for Rural Media Support Programme - [Name of your outlet and province]”.

Please note that you must only submit one Application Form, either in English or Urdu, and that applications submitted using different templates or formats shall not be accepted. 

The deadline for submission is September 15th, 2024. Please note that only complete applications sent within the deadline will be taken into consideration.

Selection procedure

Applications will be reviewed by a Selection Committee based on the following selection criteria:

  1. Financial and editorial independence
  2. Shown commitment to gender mainstreaming and inclusion
  3. Active engagement in public interest journalism
  4. Commitment to an intensive two-year programme
  5. Potential for growth
  6. Engaged audience

The Selection Committee will conduct a thorough review of all submitted applications and compile a shortlist of media outlets considered most suitable for the programme, based on the information provided in the Application Form. Shortlisted candidates will be invited to participate in an interview as part of the final selection process. 

Applicants will be notified about the final status of their application maximum 1 month after the closure of the call for applications.

Financial Support

Please note that transport and accommodation costs of participants throughout the duration of the programme will be covered by the organizers.

For any queries or further information, please contact ruralmediasupport@protonmail.com 

August 15, 2024 - Comments Off on July 2024 Newsletter: DRF at International Conference on Addressing Technology Facilitated Violence Against Women (TFVAW)

July 2024 Newsletter: DRF at International Conference on Addressing Technology Facilitated Violence Against Women (TFVAW)

The International Conference on Addressing TFVAW was held in Seoul, Republic of South Korea from 1-2 July, to foster dialogue on the challenges and best practices in implementing policy measures to address TFVAW. The conference brought together 150 stakeholders, including experts dedicated to TFVAW measurement, policy, and prevention, and specifically focused on the measurement, prevalence, victim support, and regulatory frameworks and policies related to TFVAW. To that end, DRF presented its Cyber Harassment Helpline project, and how it operates, advocates for survivors, and collects and analyzes data for research.

Policy Initiatives:

More than 60 Journalists and Media Practitioners Across Pakistan Condemn the Sexist and Derogatory Statements Made by Dr. Omer Adil Against Women in Media

Read the entire statement here.

Personal Data Protection Social Media Awareness Campaign

                   

#PrivacyIsARight campaign - DRF launched a social media awareness campaign that delved into the different aspects of the landscape of privacy in Pakistan and personal data protection bill.

These included but were not limited to: Do You Know Your Data and Privacy Rights? Exploring the crucial aspects of the Personal Data Protection Bill 2023, Understanding Consent in Data Protection, and Understanding Data Controllers and Data Processors.

Press Coverage:

Nighat Dad in “Haibatnaak Surat-e-Haal” by SOC films

“Haibatnaak Surat-e-Haal” by SOC films delves into the stark reality of cyber harassment victims in Pakistan. Naila Rind’s tragic story underscores the intense societal pressure and victim-blaming that silences women, sometimes leading to heartbreaking outcomes. Featuring insights from our founder, Nighat Dad, this documentary sheds light on these critical issues.

Our Cyber Harassment Helpline stats, quoted here, reveal a troubling trend: women face relentless online abuse with few avenues for justice due to societal mistrust and legal shortcomings.

Watch the entire documentary here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SlnMnNW7O90

DRF in Press:

Voice.pk Toxic talk: The alarming rise of misogynistic content https://voicepk.net/2024/07/toxic-talk-the-alarming-rise-of-misogynistic-content/
The Express Tribune Telcos running mass surveillance system under PTA’s orders https://tribune.com.pk/story/2476503/telcos-running-mass-surveillance-system-under-ptas-orders
VOA Pakistan hearings on surveillance, TikTok worry digital rights advocates https://www.voanews.com/a/pakistan-hearings-on-surveillance-tiktok-worry-digital-rights-advocates-/7689948.html
Arab News Rights activists raise privacy concerns after Pakistan authorizes top spy agency to tap calls, messages https://www.arabnews.pk/node/2546556/pakistan
Daily Pakistan Rights activists raise privacy concerns as Pakistan authorizes spy agency to tap phone calls, messages https://en.dailypakistan.com.pk/09-Jul-2024/rights-activists-raise-privacy-concerns-as-pakistan-authorizes-spy-agency-to-tap-phone-calls-messages
APC Civil society joint brief on the UN Global Digital Compact: What's at stake for internet governance and human rights https://www.apc.org/en/pubs/civil-society-joint-brief-un-global-digital-compact-whats-stake-internet-governance-and-human
Access Now #KeepItOn: Bangladesh’s government must restore internet access, ensure connectivity during student protests https://www.accessnow.org/press-release/keepiton-restore-internet-during-student-protests-bangladesh/
The Friday Times Sexist, Derogatory Statements By Dr Omer Adil Against Women in Media Condemned https://thefridaytimes.com/25-Jul-2024/sexist-derogatory-statements-by-dr-omer-adil-against-women-in-media-condemned

Events:

Anti-Cyberbullying and Digital Awareness session

               

On Tuesday, 23 July 2024, the DRF Legal and Digital Security team conducted an informative session on "Anti-Cyberbullying & Digital Awareness" with 50 O-Level and A-Level students at Fatima Memorial's NUR Foundation in Lahore. This engaging session empowered students with strategies to counter cyberbullying and stay safe in online spaces. The session also delved into legal avenues for addressing harassment and scams.

Instagram Live - Pakistan’s Privacy Landscape: Data Protection and Article 14

DRF held an Instagram Live about Pakistan’s Privacy Landscape: Data Protection and Article 14 with digital safety experts such as Mubariz Khan - Founding Partner of Carbon Law, Farieha Aziz - Co-founder of Bolo Bhi, and Irum Shujah - Advocate High Courts.

They dove into crucial topics, moderated by Zainab Durrani - Senior Program Manager at DRF, such as: Constitutional privacy & dignity in Pakistan, Recent legal developments affecting privacy, Data protection in the digital age, Emerging online privacy threats, especially with GenAI, and Best practices for safeguarding your data.

Meta Community Summit 2024

DRF team recently attended an in-person session in Islamabad organized by meta titled as “Meta Community Summit 2024” on 2nd July 2024. The morning session consisted of various briefings on meta community standards, deep diving into their safety policies, understanding the functioning of National Center for Missing and Exploited Children, content moderation and best practices to grow your reach. The afternoon session was a closed door trusted partner session focusing on trusted partner impact, introduction of changes and deep diving into content related issues and feedback from trusted partners.

 

Online Safety and Cyber Harassment Session

DRF’s Digital Security Trainer and Legal Associate delivered a session on “Online Safety and Cyber Harassment” at the Learning Hub College Gujranwala on 04 July 2024. The session was delivered to over 500 students to raise awareness about digital safety to combat online abuse and to provide an overview of laws related to cyber harassment and online violence.

Meta's Session on Data Privacy in the Age of AI: Managing Data Across Borders

DRF legal team recently attended an online session organized by Meta, titled "Data Privacy in the Age of AI: Managing Data Across Borders" held on 26 July 2024. The session covered the concepts of cross-border data flow and data localization, focusing on balancing the free flow of data with ensuring its security. Additionally, the role of AI in handling personal data was discussed, highlighting the opportunities and challenges this technology presents. Throughout the session, key topics covered included data protection and privacy in the age of AI.

LEAD Impact Lab at Lincoln Corner NUST

DRF’s legal team recently conducted a comprehensive training session at the LEAD Impact Lab at Lincoln Corner NUST, focusing on cyber crimes, their prevention, and response strategies. The three-day summer tech camp covered essential topics, including:

  • Basics of cyber crimes
  • PECA law
  • Cyber bullying and stalking

The session concluded with a thought-provoking Q&A session, providing attendees with a platform to engage in meaningful discussions and clarify their queries. We are proud to have played a pivotal role in empowering individuals with the knowledge and skills necessary to navigate the digital landscape responsibly.

TikTok for Non-Profits

On 30th July 2024,  DRF’s Communications Team attended a training session focused on 'how to create content' and 'best practices for nonprofits on TikTok'. It was an hour long webinar, with support from TikTok’s Content Partnership team.

Punjab Protection of Women Against Violence Act 2016 consultative workshop

On July 27, 2024, our legal team actively participated in a consultative workshop focused on the Punjab Protection of Women Against Violence Act 2016. The event brought together a panel of esteemed lawyers, women protection officers, AGHS representatives, and other key stakeholders to discuss the law's provisions and address challenges faced by lawyers when obtaining court orders.

The workshop provided a valuable platform for in-depth discussions on the upcoming rules and regulations, allowing our team to gather insights from attendees and contribute to the development of more practical and effective implementation of the law. Our participation demonstrates DRF's commitment to promoting women's rights and safety, and we look forward to continuing our efforts in this crucial area.

DRF took part in PILDAT's session on creating district profiles

Digital Rights Foundation attended a session on assessing the informational needs of Civil Society Organizations and citizens, gauging what tools they need to hold governments accountable. The session aimed at creating the content and format of the proposed 24 District Profiles and 4 Citizens Guides on local governments which would enable CSOs and citizens to effectively monitor governmental and political processes. DRF suggested digitizing the citizen guides and incorporating gender-specific data, while keeping the privacy of citizens intact. The participating CSOs were also informed about the Cyber Harassment Helpline, to help raise awareness in their respective cities.

DRF Updates:

Cyber Harassment Helpline

                       

The Cyber Harassment Helpline received 359 complaints in total in July 2024, with 209 complaints by women. If you’re encountering a problem online, you can reach out to our helpline at 0800-39393, email us at helpdesk@digitalrightsfoundation.pk or reach out to us on our social media accounts. We’re available for assistance from 9 am to 5 pm, Monday to Sunday.

IWF Portal

DRF in collaboration with Internet Watch Foundation (IWF) and the Global Fund to End Violence Against Children launched a portal to combat children’s online safety in Pakistan. The new portal allows internet users in Pakistan to anonymously report child sexual abuse material in three different languages- English, Urdu, and Pashto.

www.report.iwf.org.uk/pk

StopNCII.org

                           

Meta along with Revenge Porn Helpline (RPH) has launched a portal to support victims of Non-Consensual Intimate Image Abuse (NCII). NCII is a free portal for reporting cases of sensitive or sexual content existing online. Once you report a case, the necessary steps will be taken to block the images from the platform.

https://stopncii.org/

August 6, 2024 - Comments Off on DIGITAL RIGHTS FOUNDATION PUBLIC COMMENT ON OVERSIGHT BOARD CASES 2024-007-IG-UA, 2024-008-FB-UA (EXPLICIT AI IMAGES OF FEMALE PUBLIC FIGURES)

DIGITAL RIGHTS FOUNDATION PUBLIC COMMENT ON OVERSIGHT BOARD CASES 2024-007-IG-UA, 2024-008-FB-UA (EXPLICIT AI IMAGES OF FEMALE PUBLIC FIGURES)

Submission: Research Department - Digital Rights Foundation

Aleena Afzaal - Sr. Research Associate 

Abdullah B. Tariq - Research Associate

 

Submission Date: April 30, 2024 

 

Legal Context:

Given the borderless nature of digital content, Meta should consider international legal developments as a framework for its policies. The European Union’s Digital Services Act and specific statutes from the U.S. state of California, such as AB 602, provide precedents for regulating digital content and protecting individuals against non-consensual use of their images. 

 

Irregular responses in two different cases (How such cases affect people in different regions):

It is important to note that the two cases relating to deepfake videos of women public figures  were approached and dealt with differently potentially due to difference in ethnicity and identity: one being from the Global North and the other belonging to the global majority identity. The American public figure case received a relatively immediate response whereas the case of resemblance to a public figure in India was not highlighted or amplified as quickly. Despite the technical discrepancies, it cannot be ignored that in the latter case, an Instagram account with several similar images remained unflagged for a long time. Additionally, one question that arises continuously from a string of these cases is why have tech platforms not adopted technological mechanisms that can flag sensitive content, particularly deepfakes circulating on different platforms. The harms prevailing due to the emerging technologies particularly generative AI content need to be viewed through a more intersectional lens. Women and marginalized groups in the global majority particularly from South Asia are more vulnerable to attacks online with a significant impact on their online and offline safety rather than individuals from the global North. While female security and inclusion is crucial, the potential otherization of the community is concerning and needs to be revisited. 

 

Moreover, taking cultural context into account, the level of scrutiny and criticism a South Asian female is subjected to in such events is higher as compared to a woman of American descent. In India, a woman is viewed as good only if she is able to maintain the respect and honor of her family. Female bodies are sexualized and any attack on them is considered to be an attack on men and the community's honor. Several cases have come forward in the past where women and young girls in India have taken their own lives as a result of leaked photos. In the wider Indian subcontinent region, cases have arisen where women have been subjected to honor killing as a consequence of being romantically involved with a man, their explicit photos being leaked and more. Such cases in the region showcase an underlying problem where women and honor are used as interchangeable terms and need to be taken into consideration when handling issues of similar nature. Public figures or not, women are more prone to being targeted by AI-generated content and deepfakes. Recently, incidents have come forward where deepfakes of two female public figures in Pakistan have been made widely available across different social media platforms. As far as Meta’s platforms are concerned, these deepfakes have been uploaded with nudity being covered with the use of stickers and emojis however in the comments section, users have offered and/or asked to share the link to view the originally created content. It is crucial that platforms like Meta have mechanisms in place where content and comments amplifying technology-facilitated gender-based violence are also flagged. Considering the higher probability combined with the societal consequences, it is essential for Meta to give greater consideration to cases involving deepfakes and AI-generated content showcasing characteristics of technology-facilitated gender-based violence more importance on the platform, particularly with countries from the global majority where the risk of potential harm is higher than others.  Human reviewers should also be made aware of the language and cultural context of the cases under consideration. Trusted partners of Meta should be entrusted with the task of escalating the cases, where the response time of prioritized cases is expedited and addressed at the earliest.   

 

Clarification and Expansion of Community Guidelines:

Meta’s current community standards need to be more explicit in defining violations involving AI-generated content. There is an urgent need to develop a specific section for public-facing community guidelines on the platform to address deepfakes. Detailing examples and outlining repercussions would clarify the company's stance for users and content moderators alike. Public figures are at a higher risk of being victims of deep fake content due to their vast exposure (reference imagery) in online spaces. Thus, the policy rationale and the consequent actions need to be similar in the case of public figures and private individuals considering the sensitivity of such content regardless of an individual’s public exposure. It is equally important that Meta revises its policy regarding sensitive content where the person being imitated is not tagged. The policy needs to be inclusive of such content as the potential harms remain. Regular updates to these guidelines are crucial as AI technology evolves.

 

Technical Mechanisms for Enhanced Detection and Response: 

  • Implementing cutting-edge machine learning techniques to detect deepfake content (image, video and audio) can significantly reduce the spread of harmful content. These algorithms should focus on detecting common deepfake anomalies and be regularly updated to keep pace with technological advancements. A two pronged approach can be utilized for detecting and flagging harmful content on their platforms. Larger investments should be placed in automated detection systems to efficiently categorize and identify generative AI content and be adaptable to future advancements. 
  • Detected Gen AI content should be marked on Meta platforms to avoid confusion or the spread of misinformation. Meta needs to reassess its appeals pipeline and allow for extended review times, especially for content that contains any human likeness. Moreover, Meta needs to reassess its appeals pipeline and allow for extended review times, especially for content that contains any human likeness.
  • Collaborating with AI developers to embed watermarks in AI-generated content can help automatically identify and segregate unauthorized content. This would bolster Meta's ability to preemptively block the dissemination of harmful material. 
  • Expanding this database to include international cases and allowing for real-time updates can enhance its effectiveness in identifying and removing known violating content swiftly.
  • Meta should build on and enhance the capacity of its trusted partners particularly in terms of escalating content to the platform and having a robust and quick escalation channel in case of emergencies or content that is life-threatening. Meta needs to have emergency response mechanisms in place and have policy teams who are sensitized to deal with matters of utmost urgency particularly when it relates to marginalized groups and vulnerable communities.

 

The current challenges faced by Meta in managing AI-generated content are largely due to its lack of specificity in its policies to encapsulate generative AI content. The community standards in their current state fail to address the complexities of AI-generated content and the adverse impacts it can have on people and communities. Meta’s clear differentiation in its policy application rationale for two different cases raises concerns over irregular and inefficient content moderation policies. While we acknowledge that content in both these cases is no longer on the platform, the urgency displayed in taking down content from the second case compared to the delay in the removal from the first case highlights the dire need for stringent and equitable response of social media platforms on gen-AI content. Moreover, in the second case the deepfake video of an American woman public figure was removed under the policy “Bullying and Harassment, specifically for "derogatory sexualised photoshop or drawings"” – Greater discourse is required over what classifies as “derogatory” in this context. In the absence of a derogatory element, will an AI-generated image that involves sexualisation and nudity be available to view on the platform? If so, then how is Meta perceiving the consensual privacy and dignity of public figures on its platforms? These are the questions that need to be addressed and outlined in Meta’s content moderation policies, especially in terms of tech-facilitated gender-based violence.

 

Meta’s Media Matching Service Banks are restricted by the database of known images, which renders them highly ineffective against newly generated deepfake content. With tools to create generative AI content becoming increasingly accessible, the technology to flag and address such content needs to catch up as soon as possible. It is essential for Meta to expand its database to encompass a wider array of AI-generated content types and implement real-time updates. 

 

In conclusion, Meta’s automated detection systems struggle to keep pace with rapidly advancing sophisticated technologies used in deepfake content. For Meta to ensure safety on its platforms for marginalized groups and communities, it is essential for them to revisit their content moderation policies pertaining to generative AI content while enhancing and investing in its trusted civil society partners to escalate content towards the platform.

 

 

July 25, 2024 - Comments Off on More than 60 Journalists and Media Practitioners Across Pakistan Condemn the Sexist and Derogatory Statements Made by Dr. Omer Adil Against Women in Media

More than 60 Journalists and Media Practitioners Across Pakistan Condemn the Sexist and Derogatory Statements Made by Dr. Omer Adil Against Women in Media

IMMEDIATE RELEASE 

PRESS RELEASE

25 July 2024

Pakistan: Network of Women Journalists for Digital Rights (NWJDR) strongly condemns Dr. Omer Adil’s recent derogatory and sexist statements against Gharidah Farooqi  and women working in the media in an online program by vlogger Zohaib Saleem Butt. The online vlog has been extremely triggering with the use of graphic language against women journalists in the country.

 

The use of these sexist and abusive words for women working in the media have been repeatedly used by male journalists and colleagues in the past too. This is not the first time that female journalists and anchors have been a target of hate speech, threats and defamation. Time and again women journalists have raised their concerns with relevant authorities and demanded justice however no punitive action is taken to provide them with protection. 

 

It is also pertinent to mention that the World Press Freedom Index already marks Pakistan at 152 out of 180 countries on press freedom and there’s been repeated orchestrated and sophisticated attacks against women journalists with gendered disinformation, hateful slurs, and technology-facilitated gender-based violence (TFGBV) in the country. The Digital Rights Foundation’s Cyber Harassment Helpline Report 2023 has also been receiving repeated complaints from journalists based on the attacks they face online and in 2023 alone 35 journalists filed a complaint with the helpline.

 

These comments increase the chances of violence in offline spaces for women working in the media and can have a lasting impact on their mental health. Women journalists already lack institutional support from families and workplaces and with comments like these made by senior journalists it only reinforces negative stereotypical personas of women working in the media and also directly poses threats to their economic livelihoods. 

 

The NWJDR demands full accountability from Dr. Omar Adil for maligning female journalists in the video. A public apology is insufficient to address the profound damage inflicted on the reputation of all women journalists. Furthermore, we assert that the apology from video host Zohaib Saleem Butt is grossly inadequate and fails to mitigate the harm caused by the misogynistic statements made in the video. 

 

We call on relevant government bodies, journalist protection organizations, and regional and national press clubs to unequivocally condemn the use of such language against women in the media. They must actively discourage its perpetuation through online content and vlogs and take punitive action against those disseminating this harmful content.

 

Signatures: 

  1. Asma Kundi DW urdu freelancer
  2. Mahwish Fakhar, Dawn, Islamabad
  3. Dr. Tehreem Azeem, Assistant Professor, Department of Mass Communication, NUST 
  4. Ayesha Khalid, Comms Manager, Facter Lead, Media Matters for Democracy
  5. Gharidah Farooqi, anchor, Gtv
  6. Afia Salaam, journalist
  7. Madiha Abid Ali, Anchor person, PTV News Islamabad
  8. Qurrat ul Ain Shirazi, journalist.
  9. Mehr Hussain, The Friday Times
  10. Fauzia Yazdani
  11. Riffat Anjum, Journalist
  12. Amber Shamsi, Journalist
  13. Fatima Nazish, Multimedia editor DW news
  14. Amel Ghani - Journalist Lahore
  15. Bushra Pasha Foreign Correspondent DW Urdu
  16. Umaima Ahmed, Global Voices
  17. Fauzia Kalsoom Rana, Founder and Convenor Women journalists Association of Pakistan WJAP, Broadcast Journalist
  18. Yashfeen Jamal, Anchorperson, Neo news
  19. Ramna Saeed Yeni Șafak international correspondent
  20. Sheema Siddiqui, Geo TV karachi
  21. Xari Jalil, Voice.pk
  22. Sabahat khan, Freelance journalist
  23. FahmidahYousfi, journalist
  24. Khalida niaz, Radio Mashaal
  25. Ayesha Saghir, Reporter Express News Lahore
  26. Lubna Jarar Naqvi, Journalist
  27. Bushra Iqbal, multimedia journalist/ anchor person
  28. Javeria Siddique Columnist Dunya Newspaper and Journalist working for Trt Urdu.
  29. Najia Mir, Anchor person/ Senior Producer, KTN News
  30. Sadia Hyat Khan, CEO of Zenith Media, actor anchor producer.
  31. Shama Siddiqui journalist Anchor person  News Reader
  32. Mehmal Sarfraz, Journalist
  33. Shiba Gill, Anchor person: Lahore Chamber of commerce and industry
  34. Aneela Ashraf freelance Multan
  35. Farah Naz, b chief & Reporter Daily Aghaz e Safar, Editor Weekly Sholla
  36. Absa Komal, Dawn Tv
  37. Maryam Zia, Anchor PTV World
  38. Amer Malik, Senior Correspondent, The News International
  39. Wasif Shakil, Senior News Editor, Geo News
  40. Moazzam S. Bhatti, Journalist
  41. Zoya Anwer, Freelance Journalist
  42. Zebunnisa Burki -- Journalist
  43. Tarhub Asghar - BBC journalist
  44. Mahjabeen Abid, freelance journalist / Multan
  45. Amina Usman Anchor person & Chairperson Of Media leading Ladies
  46. Dr. Rabia Noor, ARY NEWS
  47. Sana Asif BBC Pvt Ltd Broadcast Journalist
  48. Imrana Komal, Freelancer
  49. Wajeeha Aslam, Manager Special project Samaa news
  50. Fareeha Idrees, anchor of GNN. 
  51. Dr.Hayam Qayyoum, Assistant Professor department of media Studies. Bahria University Islamabad
  52. Hafsa Javed Khawaja, Journalism for Human Rights 
  53. Sabah Malik, CityFM89, Dawn Media 
  54. Aliya Jabeen, journalist 
  55. Afshan Masab, Multimedia journalist, CEO NativeMedia
  56. Faiz Paracha, Correspondent, Pro Pakistani & Daily News Diplomacy
  57. Sumeira Ashraf, head of assignment & planning, 24 News HD, Islamabad
  58. Sarah B. Haider, Journalist
  59. Saweera Mustafa, Producer G For Gharida, Gtv
  60. Rabbia Arshad journalist - multimedia journalist/documentary maker
  61. Dr. Sana Ghori ( Metro One News ) Karachi
  62. Arifa Noor, anchor, Dawn
  63. Sehrish Qureshi Producer - Independent Urdu, Joint Secretary - National Press Club
  64. Sanam Junejo, Associated press of Pakistan, Reporter/subeditor

 

Digital Rights Foundation is a registered research-based NGO in Pakistan. Founded in 2012, DRF focuses on ICTs to support human rights, inclusiveness, democratic processes, and digital governance. DRF works on issues of online free speech, privacy, data protection and online violence against women.

 

For more information log on: www.digitalrightsfoundation.pk 

Facebook 

Twitter/X 

Instagram

Tiktok 

Contact

Nighat Dad 

nighat@digitalrightsfoundation.pk 

Seerat Khan

seerat@digitalrightsfoundation.pk

Umaima Ahmad

umaima@digitalrightsfoundation.pk

Anam Baloch

anam@digitalrightsfoundation.pk

For press/media inquiries: communications@digitalrightsfoundation.pk

 

 

July 15, 2024 - Comments Off on Technology-facilitated Gendered Surveillance on the Rise in Women’s Private Spaces 

Technology-facilitated Gendered Surveillance on the Rise in Women’s Private Spaces 

7th June 2024

Pakistan: Digital Rights Foundation (DRF) is extremely alarmed and concerned about the ongoing surveillance of women and girls in private spaces through unregulated CCTV cameras in women's shelters, hostels, universities and salons, invading their right to privacy and dignity in private spaces. Women are already exceedingly subjected to gender based violence, harassment and social surveillance by society which in turn pushes them to seek refuge in gender segregated private spaces such as these. 

 

According to the 2023 Gender Gap report Pakistan ranks at 142 out of 146 countries in terms of gender parity, including economic participation and opportunity, educational attainment, health and survival, and political empowerment. With women’s participation being severely limited and restricted in the country, they are significantly more financially dependent, prompting them to look towards spaces like Dar-ul-Amans (designated shelters for women in distress) for shelter and protection. Women residing in Dar-ul-Amans are largely vulnerable, particularly when they face little to no familial support and are seeking refuge. 

 

Dar-ul-Amans in the country have been purpose-built to provide state-sanctioned  support at an institutional level. In light of this, the use of unregulated CCTV cameras is flagrantly threatening and targeting women’s dignity and privacy. This an active and  gross violation of their constitutional rights as granted under Article 14. Additionally, S. 9(5) of the Guidelines for Dar-Ul-Aman in Punjab also recognizes these rights and states that ‘violation of a resident’s privacy shall be considered as misconduct and the Social Welfare Department shall be justified in taking appropriate action in this regard.’

 

Women living in these shelters have also complained of gross mistreatment and abuse at the hands of those in charge at these centers. Days before the Rawalpindi Dar-ul-Aman incident, another incident of a similar nature took place in one of Lahore’s women’s hostels where hidden cameras were found on the premises of the building. These repeated instances of CCTV cameras being installed in private spaces under the guise of safety and the footage being misused , serve as a direct invasion of privacy and threat to women’s physical safety and create a hostile environment of mistrust and insecurity amongst women at large. 

 

There have even been reports of instances of  CCTV cameras being installed to surveil women in salons, where the footage and data has later been employed as blackmail material. In 2019, students from University of Balochistan (UoB) protested in the wake of CCTV camera footage being used by security personnels to sexually harass and blackmail students, particularly the young women on campus. In the past, we have seen that the Senate Standing Committee on Human Rights have taken notice of these issues and we urge them to exercise their position to do the same now and investigate these heinous acts of violation against women’s privacy at Dar-ul-Amans and other private spaces. 

 

DRF's Cyber Harassment Helpline since its inception has received 16,849 complaints from across Pakistan, with 58.5% of the complaints having been received from women across the country. Over the years we have received a number of complaints where women have repeatedly complained about being targeted through surveillance & spyware technologies injected to their devices by individuals who are close to them in order to control and monitor their movements and activities. We have also witnessed a rising trend where women were captured on camera without their consent in addition to the misuse of their intimate images through blackmail and intimidation. In some instances these images are further manipulated and doctored through the use of  generative AI tools to create deep fakes visuals and imagery.

 

We strongly urge transparent and urgent investigations into these violative incidents which are (of employing the use of unregulated CCTV cameras to violate women’s privacy) contributing to increased gender surveillance in the country. DRF has long been advocating for a human rights centric personal data protection law for this very reason, which needs to be centering the   privacy and data of vulnerable communities including women, gender minorities and marginalized groups. We urge the current Ministry of Human Rights (MoHR) and Ministry of Information Technology & Telecommunication (MoITT) to involve women rights and digital rights groups in consultations around the proposed data protection bill in order to address the existing gaps. Moreover, we urge the National Commission on Human Rights (NCHR) and National Commission of Women Rights (NCWR) to look into the matter post haste and ensure that women are not subjected to gender based violence at the hands of technology, particularly in the form of their surveillance in private and public spaces. 

 

Digital Rights Foundation is a registered research-based NGO in Pakistan. Founded in 2012, DRF focuses on ICTs to support human rights, inclusiveness, democratic processes, and digital governance. DRF works on issues of online free speech, privacy, data protection and online violence against women.

 

For more information log on: www.digitalrightsfoundation.pk 

Facebook 

Twitter/X 

Instagram

Tiktok 

Contact

Nighat Dad 

nighat@digitalrightsfoundation.pk 

Seerat Khan

seerat@digitalrightsfoundation.pk

Anam Baloch

anam@digitalrightsfoundation.pk

July 15, 2024 - Comments Off on June 2024 Newsletter: Digital Rights Foundation raises alarm over Technology Facilitated Gendered Surveillance on the rise in Women’s Spaces

June 2024 Newsletter: Digital Rights Foundation raises alarm over Technology Facilitated Gendered Surveillance on the rise in Women’s Spaces

June 2024 Newsletter: Digital Rights Foundation raises alarm over Technology Facilitated Gendered Surveillance on the rise in Women’s Spaces

Digital Rights Foundation is extremely alarmed and concerned about the ongoing surveillance of women and girls in private spaces through unregulated CCTV cameras in women's shelters, hostels, universities and salons, invading their right to privacy and dignity in private spaces. Women are already exceedingly subjected to gender based violence, harassment and social surveillance by society which in turn pushes them to seek refuge in gender segregated private spaces such as these. 

 

For more details, click here.

 

Policy Initiatives: 

 

International Day for Countering Hate Speech

On this International Day for Countering Hate Speech, DRF reflected on the importance of religious tolerance and the Supreme Court's 2014 directive to combat hate speech online against religious minorities in Pakistan. 

 

Stop Cyberbullying Day

This Stop Cyberbullying Day 2024, DRF wanted to highlight our Hamara Internet Mahfooz Internet Project. Through our digital literacy sessions in Lahore's government schools, we educate students and teachers on digital safety, cyber harassment, and ways to combat cyberbullying.

 

Press Coverage: 

Nighat Dad on Zara Hat Ke

DRF’s Executive Director, Nighat Dad, discussed the Punjab Defamation Bill and improper use of CCTV cameras in private areas with Dawn News' Zara Hat Ke program.

 

Watch the entire panel here.

 

Nighat Dad on Geo News

Nighat Dad spoke about online hate speech and trolling on Geo Pakistan.

 

Hate speech has permeated Pakistani society to such an extent that it is now considered a structural issue. On a global scale, a great deal of political dog whistling has made hate speech more prevalent among the populace. Not only should states and leaders be held accountable for such actions, but social media platforms where these occur should also be held accountable. To combat hate and prevent it from engulfing us, we, the actual public, must lead the change through discussions, dialogues, and counternarratives. 

 

Watch the entire discussion here.

 

Global Voices Advox The latest defamation bill further tightens restrictions on free speech in Pakistan https://advox.globalvoices.org/2024/05/30/the-latest-defamation-bill-further-tightens-restrictions-on-free-speech-in-pakistan/
Capital Research Center Misinformation and Checking the Fact-Checkers: Pushing Censorship https://capitalresearch.org/article/misinformation-and-checking-the-fact-checkers-part-4/
Dawn Alarm over surveillance of girls in private spaces https://www.dawn.com/news/1838477/alarm-over-surveillance-of-girls-in-private-spaces
Dawn Hidden cams https://www.dawn.com/news/1838914/hidden-cams
The News Not so hidden agenda https://www.thenews.com.pk/print/1199462-not-so-hidden-agenda
Times of India Pakistan: Human Rights body raises concern about situation in Kyber Pakhtunkhwa https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/world/pakistan/pakistan-human-rights-body-raises-concern-about-situation-in-khyber-pakhtunkhwa/articleshow/110925261.cms
The News Enough is enough https://www.thenews.com.pk/print/1199465-enough-is-enough
News on Air Pakistan Human Rights Commission Raises Alarms On Human Rights And Law Enforcement In Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Province https://www.newsonair.gov.in/pakistan-human-rights-commission-raises-alarms-on-human-rights-and-law-enforcement-in-khyber-pakhtunkhwa-province/
My Ind Human Rights Body in Pakistan voices concern over Khyber Pakhtunkhwa situation https://myind.net/Home/viewArticle/human-rights-body-in-pakistan-voices-concern-over-khyber-pakhtunkhwa-situation
The Khaama Press Surge in Hidden Camera Incidents in Pakistan’s Girls’ Hostels Raises Alarm https://www.khaama.com/surge-in-hidden-camera-incidents-in-pakistans-girls-hostels-raises-alarm/
Business Recorder Violation of women’s privacy https://www.brecorder.com/news/40308746
The News Battle for privacy https://www.thenews.com.pk/print/1201108-battle-for-privacy
National Endowment for Democracy Manufacturing deceit how generative AI supercharges information manipulation https://www.ned.org/events/manufacturing-deceit-how-generative-ai-supercharges-information-manipulation/

 

Events:

Nighat Dad at Palestine Digital Activism Forum (PDAF) 2024 

At PDAF, Meedan’s workshop featured Dr. Dima Saber and Dr. Scott A. Hale alongside Nighat Dad, founder and executive director of the Digital Rights Foundation (DRF) in Pakistan. Taysir Mathlouthi of 7amleh — The Arab Center for the Advancement of Social Media moderated the panel. The session focused on fine-tuning large language models (LLMs) for the Larger World, Meedan’s preferred term for the Global South.

 

PDAF 2024 was centered on the theme “Artificial Intelligence: Revolutionary Promises and Discriminatory Realities.”

 

Nighat Dad at the International Forum for Democratic Studies for the release of “Manufacturing Deceit: How Generative AI Supercharges Information Manipulation” by Beatriz Saab

Nighat Dad, DRF’s Executive Director, as she joins the virtual discussion on how generative AI supercharges information manipulation. 

 

This event marks the launch of the new Forum report, “Manufacturing Deceit” by Beatriz Saab

 

DRF at the PI Partner Convening

DRF was represented at the Privacy International Partner Convening by Senior Program Manager Zainab Durrani from June 17th to June 20th 2024.

The Partner Convening is a meeting of organizations and individuals focused on defending the universal right to privacy through research, advocacy and providing community support. 

The PI Partner Convening saw a host of privacy defenders and advocates from Columbia, Brazil, Mexico, India, Kenya, Portugal and other countries join in to discuss, strategize and congregate on key developments in the privacy sphere across the globe.

Zainab Durrani, who manages DRF’s data privacy portfolio, presented to the conference on two key themes: tech facilitated gender based violence and tech perspectives from the Global Majority, over the span of the 3-day event.

 

Digital Literacy and Citizenship Bootcamp at the Karakoram International University

The DRF team, led by Senior Program Manager Zainab Durrani conducted its second Digital Literacy and Citizenship Bootcamp at the Karakoram International University (KIU)in Gilgit.

The Bootcamp project is supported by the U.S Embassy Islamabad and the opening ceremony for this intensive program was held at KIU on June 1st, 2024.

The keynote speaker was Ms. Alejandra Baez of the U.S Embassy Islamabad and Dr. Ataullah Shah, Vice Chancellor of KIU delivered the welcome note at the event.

The Digital Literacy Bootcamp is a 10-day capacity building program designed to inculcate key concepts such as legal knowledge, social science research, digital safety, digital etiquettes, AI and LLMs and the impact of the disinformation ecosystem, in the participants. 

This Bootcamp was attended by 61 students from various departments at KIU and carried out successfully by various subject matter experts from DRF.

 

DRF accompanied the NCHR Team to the government Dar ul Amaan Rawalpindi  

DRF’s representative, Irum Shujah, joined National Commission of Human Rights’ (NCHR) team on a visit to Dar ul Amaan, Rawalpindi to inspect surveillance cameras within the premises and ensure the privacy and security of residents. The visit was prompted by social media concerns about women's privacy in such facilities. The relevant teams are reviewing their findings and will share recommendations with stakeholders to safeguard residents' rights.

 

Online Safety Workshop in Hunza

The DRF team conducted an Online Safety Workshop in collaboration with IEI Pakistan in Hunza and it was truly enlightening. Empowering girls and women to navigate the digital world safely and confidently is at the heart of our mission for #HamaraInternetMahfoozInternet. Despite the diverse age groups and skill levels, more than 50 participants engaged in crucial discussions on consent, digital safety, and the importance of open communication between parents and children.

 

Anti-Cyberbullying and Digital Awareness session

DRF held a session with 55 students of O-Level and A-Level at Fatima Memorial’s NUR Foundation’s internship program in Lahore. They were informed how to counter cyberbullying, staying safe in online spaces and legal avenues to adopt incase of harassment or scams. They were also given helpline brochures. 

 

A session with Suno FM Radio 89.4-96 ( Aao Bat Krain ) 

Anmol Sajjad delivered a virtual session on online harassment on 25 June 2024, with Suno FM Radio 89.4-96 with Bushra Iqbal. The session focused on online harassment in the digital era. This also includes the discussion of consequences for minors and vulnerable communities and suggested solutions for mitigating these risks. The prevention of online harassment and digital detox were also discussed during the session. 

 

Watch the entire interaction here.

 

MoITT Consultation on May 2023 draft of Pakistan’s Personal Data Protection Bill

Irum Shujah, representing DRF, attended an in-person consultation on the May 2023 draft of Pakistan’s Personal Data Protection Bill organized by the Ministry of Information and Technology (MoITT) in Islamabad on 26 June 2024. Nighat Dad and other senior management members participated remotely and contributed insightful input. Throughout the consultation, both Nighat Dad and Irum Shujah addressed critical issues pertaining to privacy and other key aspects of the draft legislation. Nighat Dad specifically highlighted how certain law provisions infringe upon privacy concerns and create difficulties for stakeholders, emphasizing the need for these issues to be addressed. DRF also submitted comprehensive written recommendations aimed at further refining the bill.

 

Meta's Session on Data Privacy in the Age of AI

DRF legal team recently attended an online session organized by Meta, titled "Data Privacy in the Age of AI" held on 25 June 2024. The session delved into the intricacies of the Personal Data Protection Bill, discussing its critical role in safeguarding privacy. Additionally, recommendations for Pakistan's draft on personal data protection were also discussed during the session. Throughout the session, key topics covered included the definition of privacy, fundamental principles of data protection, and the rights and safeguards for managing personal data in the era of artificial intelligence.

 

 

DRF Updates: 

Cyber Harassment Helpline 

The Cyber Harassment Helpline received 266 complaints in total in June 2024, with 155 complaints by women. If you’re encountering a problem online, you can reach out to our helpline at 0800-39393, email us at helpdesk@digitalrightsfoundation.pk or reach out to us on our social media accounts. We’re available for assistance from 9 am to 5 pm, Monday to Sunday.

 

Cyber Harassment Helpline Supporting Journalists

IWF Portal

DRF in collaboration with Internet Watch Foundation (IWF) and the Global Fund to End Violence Against Children launched a portal to combat children’s online safety in Pakistan. The new portal allows internet users in Pakistan to anonymously report child sexual abuse material in three different languages- English, Urdu, and Pashto.

 

www.report.iwf.org.uk/pk 

 

StopNCII.org

Meta along with Revenge Porn Helpline (RPH) has launched a portal to support victims of Non-Consensual Intimate Image Abuse (NCII). NCII is a free portal for reporting cases of sensitive or sexual content existing online. Once you report a case, the necessary steps will be taken to block the images from the platform.

 

https://stopncii.org/

 

June 12, 2024 - Comments Off on May 2024 Newsletter: DRF successfully completes the inaugural Digital Literacy and Citizenship Bootcamp

May 2024 Newsletter: DRF successfully completes the inaugural Digital Literacy and Citizenship Bootcamp

 

 

 

Under a generous grant from the U.S Embassy Islamabad and in collaboration with the American Institute of Pakistan Studies (AIPS), the Digital Rights Foundation, led by Senior Program Manager Zainab Durrani, conducted the inaugural session of the 10-Day Digital Literacy and Citizenship Bootcamp at the University of Karachi between April 22nd and May 3rd, 2024. 

 

The Bootcamp was attended by 63 students from the Department of Public Administration. The Digital Literacy Bootcamp has been designed to build the capacity of university students on key digital rights issues like digital literacy, online information landscape, digital safety and digital citizenship, keeping in mind that online spaces are now reflective of our lived experiences in our offline lives and with our digital profiles opening new avenues for us, it is crucial to be aware of our rights as digital citizens. The Bootcamp comprises a series of 40+ modules that are designed and aimed at fostering the knowledge of digital citizens in Pakistan in online safety skills to navigate online spaces more effectively. 

 

Policy Initiatives: 

World Press Freedom Day 2024

On World Press Freedom Day 2024, we celebrated the resilient voices of female journalists and our 200+ members strong Network of Women Journalists for Digital Rights (NWJDR).

 

DRF joins organizations in the Global South Alliance  in issuing a statement about their position on the UN Global Digital Compact (GDC) and Summit of the Future

The organizations would like the global body to address pressing issues for civil society in the digital rights sphere with a focus on several areas including Internet access, Research and Data access. They are also expressing concern over the global distribution of risks and opportunities offered by existing and emerging technologies. As much as they welcome the process of a GDC that would contribute towards bridging gaps brought about by inequalities created by technologies, it is their position that the Global South has unique needs and priorities, influenced by unique contexts, dependencies and technology infrastructure.

 

Read the full statement here

 

World Telecommunication And Information Society Day

DRF commemorated World Telecommunication and Information Society Day by shedding light on the Digital Divide in Pakistan through a gendered lens.

 

Digital Rights Foundation joined over 80 Civil Society Organizations and Journalists in Rejecting the Punjab Defamation Bill (2024)

DRF joined over 80 civil society organizations and journalists in rejecting the Punjab Defamation Bill. The Punjab Defamation Bill (2024) is a significant infringement on freedom of expression and press freedom, serving as a draconian tool to suppress dissent, particularly targeting journalists and the public. The bill's provisions, which allow defamation actions without proof of actual damage and impose harsh fines, amount to legal intimidation tactics. By replacing district courts with tribunals, the bill enables undue interference and sets a dangerous precedent by broadly defining "journalists" and "newspapers" to include social media users. This legislation's disproportionate punishments, such as blocking social media accounts, are antithetical to democratic principles. In the statement, we urge the Punjab government to reverse this regressive effort and engage in inclusive consultations to effectively address disinformation and hate speech.

 

The Network of Women Journalists for Digital Rights (NWJDR) condemns the online abuse and threats against Absa Komal

Press Coverage: 

Nighat Dad on Al Jazeera English | How deepfakes can jeopardise the integrity of elections 

Nighat Dad discusses founding the Digital Rights Foundation a decade ago due to her experiences as a South Asian woman and observing digital rights issues in South Asia, especially Pakistan. As a lawyer focused on women's rights, she saw marginalized groups, especially women, facing significant challenges online. 

 

Initially, issues included misinformation, disinformation, digital voter suppression, and online privacy. Now, AI has exacerbated these problems, manipulating voter behavior through algorithms, generative content, and deep fakes. She emphasizes that AI-driven decision-making in elections is often unfair and discriminatory, with a severe impact on female politicians in countries like Pakistan.

 

Watch the entire panel here.

 

‘Uncharted terrain’: How officials, campaigners and fact-checkers tackle AI’s influence on elections around the world

Nighat Dad discusses the impact of generative AI on Pakistan's February election, particularly how Imran Khan's AI-cloned voice messages mobilized voters. Despite the enthusiasm around AI's potential, Dad, founder of the Digital Rights Foundation, expresses concerns over the technology's negative effects, especially the spread of deepfakes and disinformation. She highlights the risks posed to marginalized groups, including women and religious minorities, who have faced attacks through AI-generated sexualized and blasphemous content, potentially endangering their safety in Pakistan's conservative society.

 

Read the full article here.

 

Nighat Dad on Asma Sherazi’s show on  HUM News

Nighat Dad, while criticizing the Punjab Defamation Bill on Asma Shirazi's program on Hum News, stated that the bill is against freedom of expression and press freedom. She described the bill as harsh and biased, aimed at protecting government officials from accountability. Nighat Dad emphasized that the penalties proposed in the bill are disproportionate and could be used against minority groups and women.

 

Listen to her full discussion here.

 

Nighat Dad about the new Cyber Crime Agency on Aik News

Will this new Cyber Crime Agency lead to social media restrictions? Digital rights activist Nighat Dad has openly expressed her views.

 

Listen to her full talk here.

 

Seerat Khan on GTV

Seerat Khan, DRF's Program Lead, spoke with GTV News about the fear surrounding AI, particularly the proliferation of deep fake imagery. Women are the most vulnerable to this behavior, and it has the potential to permanently alter their lives.

 

Byte backlash: new cybercrime agency raises eyebrows

Nighat Dad expresses concern over the lack of consultation with civil society regarding a new cyber agency. She highlights the uncertainty and confusion surrounding the agency's formation and its impact on ongoing cybercrime cases. Dad worries about how her cybercrime helpline will function, questioning which agency to refer cases to and the fate of current cases handled by the FIA. And she emphasizes the need for clarity on these issues as they remain unresolved.

 

Read the full article here.

 

DRF in Press

The Nation Cyber Crisis https://www.nation.com.pk/10-May-2024/cyber-crisis
NOS Meta Supervisory Board: Instagram and Facebook censor Palestinians https://nos.nl/nieuwsuur/collectie/13903/artikel/2519918-toezichtraad-meta-instagram-en-facebook-censureren-palestijnen
Turkiye Newspaper Meta reveals censor allegations on Facebook, Instagram regarding Palestinian content https://www.turkiyenewspaper.com/world/22977
IRNA Facebook, Instagram censor pro-Palestinian content: Oversight Board https://en.irna.ir/news/85473681/Facebook-Instagram-censor-pro-Palestinian-content-Oversight
Aurora | Dawn The Dual Glass Ceiling https://aurora.dawn.com/news/1145113
Tribal News Network Federal Government Establishes National Cyber Crime Agency, Igniting Debate on Press Freedom https://tnnenglish.com/federal-government-establishes-national-cyber-crime-agency-igniting-debate-on-press-freedom
Dawn Confidential data leak to attract trial under Secrets Act https://www.dawn.com/news/1833374/confidential-data-leak-to-attract-trial-under-secrets-act
GTV Parenting In A Digital Age | What Are Kids Doing Online | G Utha Pakistan https://youtu.be/OOK8Ohi3uM8?feature=shared

 

Events:

Nighat Dad at UNSG AI Advisory Board Meeting in Singapore

Nighat Dad recently attended the United Nations Secretary-General's AI Advisory Board meeting in Singapore. She emphasized the importance of AI governance, ethics, and human rights, advocating for inclusive development and protection of privacy and freedom of expression. Dad called for robust regulatory frameworks to prevent misuse and discrimination, particularly against marginalized communities, highlighting her commitment to global digital rights advocacy and her role in shaping policies that balance technological advancement with human rights.

 

Safeguarding Women Against Online Abuse & Cybercrime at Shaheed Benazir Bhutto University, Peshawar

DRF’s Legal Manager, Irum Shujah, and Digital Security Trainer, Noman Fareed, conducted a workshop at Shaheed Benazir Bhutto University, Peshawar, in collaboration with the US Consulate Peshawar. The interactive session included faculty members and students from various departments. The trainers discussed the importance of digital rights and online safety, taking questions from participants throughout the workshop.

 

The legal portion of the training covered topics such as the Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act 2016, the Workplace Harassment Act, and relevant sections of the Pakistan Penal Code. Meanwhile, the digital training provided insights into basic to advanced settings of chatting apps and other tools, commonly used in academia.

 

Meta Training on Communications Tools

DRF’s Communications Team attended a training by Meta that delved deep into how content works on Meta platforms and what is the best way to highlight your own content on said platforms.

 

Research as Resistance: Convening on People’s Research for Movement Building in Asia Pacific

DRF’s Research Associate, Maryam Ali Khan, attended a three-day convening from 21st to 23rd May. During this event, she participated in a panel on "Research, AI, and Digital Rights and Justice." The discussion explored research in the context of rising digitalization and Artificial Intelligence as both a tool and a site of research, and what this means for people’s research in our region. The convening was arranged by the Asia Pacific Forum for Women, Law and Development (APWLD) in Chiang Mai, Thailand.

The aim of the convening was to build a shared understanding of how we do research for movement building in our region and the contexts we navigate to do so, explore collectively the results and impacts of feminist and peoples' research in the region, and based on our collective conversations, identify areas for support, improvement and collaboration in the region. 

 

Justice Project Pakistan organized a Consultative Dialogue with Ms. Christine Chung (UN OHCHR) on 28 May 2024

On 28 May 2024, DRF’s Legal Associate participated in a consultative dialogue with Ms. Christine Chung (UN OHCHR) which was organized by Justice Project Pakistan in Lahore. The roundtable included policy experts, lawyers, human rights activists, and civil society members to discuss strategies for engaging with the United Nations (UN) in light of Pakistan's upcoming UN Treaty Body reviews. At the start of the consultation dialogue, the upcoming reviews including (i) Pakistan's review on compliance with the Convention on the Elimination of all forms of Racial Discrimination (CERD) in August 2024, (ii) Pakistan's review on compliance with the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) in October 2024, (iii) Pakistan's review on compliance with the Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC) in January 2025, and (iv) Pakistan's review on compliance with the Convention on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (CESCR) later in 2025 were discussed. During the dialogue, stakeholders discussed issues related to human rights enforcement and the challenges faced in implementing international standards in Pakistan. The consultative dialogue was concluded with a hope to develop a strategy, involving submitting reports and letters to UN committees and special procedures, for improved and coordinated civil society engagement with the UN system at this critical juncture.

Digital Literacy session in government school under Hamara Internet Mahfooz Internet 

This month DRF held its last session in a government school in Lahore with their Digital Citizens program. 120 students (females only) and 5 teachers were informed about ways of staying safe in online spaces and reporting mechanisms in case of harassment or bullying. The participants were given gift bags with online safety resources and stationary.

 

DRF Updates: 

Cyber Harassment Helpline 

The Cyber Harassment Helpline received 398 complaints in total in May 2024, with 213 complaints by women. If you’re encountering a problem online, you can reach out to our helpline at 0800-39393, email us at helpdesk@digitalrightsfoundation.pk or reach out to us on our social media accounts. We’re available for assistance from 9 am to 5 pm, Monday to Sunday.

 

IWF Portal

DRF in collaboration with Internet Watch Foundation (IWF) and the Global Fund to End Violence Against Children launched a portal to combat children’s online safety in Pakistan. The new portal allows internet users in Pakistan to anonymously report child sexual abuse material in three different languages- English, Urdu, and Pashto.

 

www.report.iwf.org.uk/pk 

 

StopNCII.org

Meta along with Revenge Porn Helpline (RPH) has launched a portal to support victims of Non-Consensual Intimate Image Abuse (NCII). NCII is a free portal for reporting cases of sensitive or sexual content existing online. Once you report a case, the necessary steps will be taken to block the images from the platform.

 

https://stopncii.org/

May 21, 2024 - Comments Off on April 2024 Newsletter: Digital Rights Foundation released its Cyber Harassment Helpline Report for 2023

April 2024 Newsletter: Digital Rights Foundation released its Cyber Harassment Helpline Report for 2023

The Digital Rights Foundation (DRF) has released its seventh annual Cyber Harassment Helpline Report for 2023. The Helpline has completed seven years of operations since its launch in December 2016 and has received a total number of 16,849 complaints from across Pakistan. In 2023 alone a total of 2473 new complaints were received on the helpline with an average number of 206 new complaints received each month and February 2023 having the most complaints in the year.

 

Read the entire report here: https://digitalrightsfoundation.pk/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/DRFs-Cyber-Harassment-Helpline-Report-2023.pdf

 

Press Coverage:

 

The Daily Spokesman Digital Rights Foundation releases Cyber Harassment Helpline report for 2023 https://dailyspokesman.net/live/digital-rights-foundation-releases-cyber-harassment-helpline-report-for-2023/
The Public Purview DRF released seventh annual Cyber Harassment Helpline Report https://thepublicpurview.com.pk/drf-released-seventh-annual-cyber-harassment-helpline-report/
The Reporters DRF Cyber Harassment Helpline Report: Rise in Online Violence https://thereporters.pk/drf-cyber-harassment-helpline-report-rise-in-online-violence/
Dawn Report notes use of AI for violence against women https://www.dawn.com/news/1825745/report-notes-use-of-ai-for-violence-against-women
The News Women largest victims of online harassment: DRF https://e.thenews.com.pk/detail?id=295991
The Friday Times AI Among Technologies Increasingly Used To Harass Women Online In Pakistan https://thefridaytimes.com/05-Apr-2024/ai-among-technologies-increasingly-used-to-harass-women-online-in-pakistan
Voice.pk Average of 206 harassment complaints each month: DRF Helpline Report ’23 https://voicepk.net/2024/04/average-of-206-harassment-complaints-each-month-drf-helpline-report-23/
Daily Dunya https://e.dunya.com.pk/detail.php?date=2024-04-06&edition=ISL&id=7190671_44683559
Times of Karachi DRF report highlights alarming rate of online harassment against women in Pakistan https://timesofkarachi.pk/article/drf-report-highlights-alarming-rate-of-online-harassment-against-women-in-pakistan/3189
India Blooms Pakistan witnessing surge in cases related to AI use in violence against women https://www.indiablooms.com/world-details/SA/42247/pakistan-witnessing-surge-in-cases-related-to-ai-use-in-violence-against-women.html

 

Policy Initiatives: 

Digital Rights Foundation releases its annual report

This comprehensive annual report highlights DRF's efforts during the transformative year of 2023, highlighting the organization's significant milestones and notable accomplishments. At the heart of DRF's mission is an unwavering dedication to creating online spaces that are not only safer, but also more inclusive and accessible to all. This report exemplifies our core values by demonstrating the diligence and dedication we bring to our mission year after year, resulting in a tangible difference.

 

Read the entire report here:

https://digitalrightsfoundation.pk/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/DRF-Annual-Report-2023.pdf

 

Digital Rights Foundation Public Comment On Oversight Board Case 2023-038-Fb-Mr (Pakistani Parliament Speech)

In May 2023, a video was posted on Facebook by a news channel where a Pakistani politician was addressing the parliament and made comments that suggested that some public officials, including military personnel, needed to be hanged in order for the country to ‘heal itself.’ This was achieved by drawing parallels between the contemporary Pakistani political landscape and the perceived necessity for these executions with an ancient Egyptian ritual where individuals were sacrificed in the River Nile as a means of controlling flooding. Considering this, DRF submitted a comment stating that Meta should have taken down the video from Facebook in accordance with its Violence and Incitement Policy

 

However, after review the Oversight Board upheld Meta’s decision to leave up the content. The Board found that the post does not violate the Violence and Incitement Community Standard because it was shared by a media outlet seeking to inform others and therefore falls under the exception for “awareness raising.” The full decision can be read here

 

Girls in ICT Day 2024

On this Girls in ICT Day 2024, DRF held a session in the GGHS Model APS Model Town Lahore public school to emphasize the importance of developing leadership skills among young women in the field of ICT, as well as the importance of online safety and digital literacy.

 

Watch the entire coverage here: https://www.instagram.com/reel/C6Ls5mHr3Eg/?igsh=cHY4Ymlqd3MwNHli

 

Press Coverage: 

 

Rolling Stone Fake Photos, Real Harm: AOC and the Fight Against AI Porn https://www.rollingstone.com/culture/culture-features/aoc-deepfake-ai-porn-personal-experience-defiance-act-1234998491/
Compiler Harm Reduction https://www.compiler.news/harm-reduction/
The Friday Times Pakistan's Misogynistic Lord Of The Flies https://thefridaytimes.com/07-Apr-2024/pakistan-s-misogynistic-lord-of-the-flies
The Express Tribune Harassment via AI https://tribune.com.pk/story/2462141/harassment-via-ai
Dawn ‘Women more prone to online hate speech’ https://www.dawn.com/news/1830295/women-more-prone-to-online-hate-speech
The Express Tribune Parliament, judiciary urged to protect rights https://tribune.com.pk/story/2464402/parliament-judiciary-urged-to-protect-rights
IFEX Journalists who ‘crossed the line’, digital repression, blasphemy prosecutions, and marriage equality bill https://ifex.org/journalists-who-crossed-the-line-digital-repression-blasphemy-prosecutions-and-marriage-equality-bill/
The Current Asma Jahangir Conference receives flak for expelling pro-Palestinian protestors https://thecurrent.pk/asma-jahangir-conference-receives-flak-for-expelling-pro-palestinian-protestors/

 

Events:

Nighat Dad at Skoll World Forum

Nighat Dad was part of the panel at Skoll World Forum titled “Reclaiming Truth in the Age of Information Disorder''. She discussed the crucial role of credible and truthful information in sustaining democracy. She highlighted the challenges posed by emerging technologies, such as fake news and deep fakes, which complicate the identification of truth. Dad emphasizes the growing crisis of distrust in institutions and information, which is particularly critical during elections and highlighted DRF’s work such as our Cyber Harassment Helpline that helps mitigate such a crisis. 

The session also explored potential solutions to counter misinformation and restore trust in democratic processes.

 

Watch the entire panel here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7UAWPAn3Kpw&t=3s

 

Nighat Dad at the IFEX Convening 

Nighat Dad, Executive Director of the Digital Rights Foundation, attended the first in-person IFEX network convening since the COVID-19 pandemic in April. This significant event, held in Berlin, provided a rare and invaluable opportunity for over 100 member organizations from more than 70 countries to come together and deepen their collaborative efforts in defending freedom of expression and information. The gathering prioritized authentic, unstructured interactions over formal presentations, fostering vibrant corridor conversations and genuine engagement. This approach was aimed at strengthening connections and collective power, underlined by a set of newly adopted principles of collaboration.

Nighat Dad at Asma Jahangir Conference 2024 (AJCONF 2024)

DRF's Executive Director Nighat Dad talked as a panelist on the panel discussion titled “Online Hate Speech & Disinformation” at the 5th Asma Jahangir Conference held on 28 April 2024 in Lahore. The panel focused on relevant laws and regulations in Pakistan governing online hate speech and disinformation. Additionally, the discussion revolved around how social media companies enforce human rights standards, particularly concerning vulnerable communities and sexual/gender minorities. The ongoing litigation under unconstitutional laws (e.g., section 20 of the Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act 2016 and 124-A sedition of the Pakistan Penal Code 1860) was also discussed. 

 

At the end of the panel discussion, there was a call for capacity-building training for government and law enforcement personnel to improve investigation methods and evidence handling, and also an appeal for state efforts to regulate social media while safeguarding human rights by considering decriminalization of speech in general. Furthermore, the discussion highlighted the need to maintain a check on the adverse effects of social media platforms blocking free speech, financial independence, and foreign investments in Pakistan.

 

Listen to the full panel here: https://youtu.be/aMAdkriDHgw?feature=shared

 

WISE Session on Digital Inclusion: Empowering Women & Communities

DRF’s legal team attended a session hosted by WISE (Women in Struggle For Empowerment) focusing on Digital Inclusion: Empowering Women & Communities, held on April 4th, 2024 in Lahore. During the session, team members shared invaluable insights regarding the FIA Complaint Mechanism, covering reporting procedures, the support offered to victims via the DRF helpline, and the pivotal role of legal frameworks in combating online harassment or abuse. Throughout the session, our team explored the crucial role of legal frameworks in tackling online harassment or abuse, delving into challenges across physical and online spaces, and reflecting on pertinent legislation such as the Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act, 2016 (‘PECA’). 

 

Digital Citizen Program in Government Schools

After the Ramadan break and final exams, DRF held two sessions in government high schools in Lahore. 357 students (females and males) and 9 teachers were informed about ways of staying safe in online spaces and reporting mechanisms in case of harassment or bullying. The participants were given gift bags with online safety resources and stationary.

 

DRF Updates: 

Cyber Harassment Helpline 

The Cyber Harassment Helpline received 306 complaints in total in April 2024, with 148 complaints by women. If you’re encountering a problem online, you can reach out to our helpline at 0800-39393, email us at helpdesk@digitalrightsfoundation.pk or reach out to us on our social media accounts. We’re available for assistance from 9 am to 5 pm, Monday to Sunday.

 

IWF Portal

DRF in collaboration with Internet Watch Foundation (IWF) and the Global Fund to End Violence Against Children launched a portal to combat children’s online safety in Pakistan. The new portal allows internet users in Pakistan to anonymously report child sexual abuse material in three different languages- English, Urdu, and Pashto.

 

www.report.iwf.org.uk/pk 

 

StopNCII.org

Meta along with Revenge Porn Helpline (RPH) has launched a portal to support victims of Non-Consensual Intimate Image Abuse (NCII). NCII is a free portal for reporting cases of sensitive or sexual content existing online. Once you report a case, the necessary steps will be taken to block the images from the platform.

 

https://stopncii.org/

 

May 13, 2024 - Comments Off on DIGITAL RIGHTS FOUNDATION PUBLIC COMMENT ON OVERSIGHT BOARD CASE 2023-038-FB-MR (PAKISTANI PARLIAMENT SPEECH)

DIGITAL RIGHTS FOUNDATION PUBLIC COMMENT ON OVERSIGHT BOARD CASE 2023-038-FB-MR (PAKISTANI PARLIAMENT SPEECH)

Submission Author: Maryam Ali Khan
Submission Date: 23rd January, 2024

In May 2023, a video was posted on Facebook by a news channel where a Pakistani politician was addressing the parliament and made comments that suggested that some public officials, including military personnel, needed to be hanged in order for the country to ‘heal itself.’ This was achieved by drawing parallels between the contemporary Pakistani political landscape and the perceived necessity for these executions with an ancient Egyptian ritual where individuals were sacrificed in the River Nile as a means of controlling flooding. Considering this, Meta should have taken down the video from Facebook in accordance with its Violence and Incitement Policy. The policy clearly stipulates that any content containing statements targeting individuals, other than private and high-risk persons with statements that advocated or called for violence, as well as statements containing aspirational or conditional calls to violence will be removed.

The statements made by the politician in the video were clearly inflammatory and violent especially when you look at them within the context of the country’s political history and how public hangings of influential figures, such as Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, have been manipulated by those in power to advance their agendas and propagate specific narratives - narratives that have had long term consequences on the political fabric of the country. When looking at posts and content such as this, it is also important to consider the role that state institutions such as the military and judiciary have played and continue to play in Pakistani politics. Pakistan has had a history of military managing or meddling with civilian state institutions. Free press and journalism have been relentlessly monitored and restricted during these periods of military rule, with censorship and intimidation being a regular occurrence. Journalists and citizens encounter a variety of problems, including threats of assault and harassment. Pakistan currently ranks 150th out of 180 nations in the 2023 World Press Freedom Index, indicating a striking deterioration in freedom of the press. As the country progresses, it is critical that authorities take relevant steps to ensure freedom of the press, especially due to the fact that no democracy can function efficiently without it.

As Pakistan approaches its upcoming general elections scheduled for February, familiar patterns seem to be repeating themselves. Censorship of the press and journalists has been ongoing before and after Imran Khan was ousted as the Prime Minister after a no-confidence motion in April 2022. There have been multiple riots by supporters of his party since then and the Pakistan Electronic Media Regulatory Authority (PEMRA), has increasingly censored media outlets and journalists who are critical of the state. Additionally, there have been multiple state-imposed internet shutdowns in an attempt to silence dissent and disrupt online political campaigning by certain political parties. Since May 2023, former prime minister Imran Khan has been in jail, and his party members are being severely restricted by authorities from freely contesting elections.

In Pakistan, social media and digital platforms have played a huge role in amplifying journalistic freedom. These platforms allow journalists and media organizations to quickly reach a much larger audience than was conventionally possible before. However, this has also meant that a lot of journalists and news agencies have been unable to maintain their standards of what content is “newsworthy”, and many times share content that is nothing but sensational, and is intended to bring in views - which is good for business. Journalists are pressured by media houses to report and sensationalize news, reflecting the severe absence of ethical journalism standards in the industry. We have also seen a shift in the industry where news reporting is no longer a monopoly maintained by journalists. Pakistan has seen an increasing trend of

‘Youtubers,’ ‘political commentators’, and ‘influencers’ spreading disinformation under the guise of news in the country.

The speech provided no useful information and led to more instability in the country leading up to the May 9th events in the country when riots broke out in cities after Imran Khan was ousted and military official buildings were attacked. What's more alarming is that this particular speech incited public opinion towards attacking public officials who can be in the guise of military officials, politicians, and any other official believed to be working for a political opponent other than the proclaimed party who made this statement.

When determining what kind of content should be allowed to stay up on social media platforms, content moderators should keep in mind these regional and political contexts. How certain content could escalate offline and online violence should especially be considered. Freedom of speech and freedom of the press can be achieved without having to resort to blatant violent speech. In content removal and guideline development, Meta should encourage governments to adhere to appropriate protocols for submitting content removal requests. The Pakistani government has had the capability to monitor and censor online material and has in the past issued draconian laws for social media platforms in February 2020, which allow them to erase “unlawful” information within 24 hours. These restrictions have been criticized for limiting freedom of expression and stifling dissent of users online. The 2016 Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act (PECA) also gives authorities powers to monitor and prohibit internet information. Therefore, it is essential that the government establishes a well-defined set of guidelines and protocols that prioritize human rights guiding principles and the freedom of the press. The justification for content removal should not be based on its opposition to the state or its advocacy for causes such as women's and trans rights - which are often misunderstood as ‘un Islamic,’ ‘immoral,’ ‘vulgar’ and ‘immodest.’

These steps will help in the democratization and de-escalation of political tensions both in online and offline platforms, while simultaneously improving the quality of journalism in the country.

*To the read the Oversight Board’s full decision on this case:

https://www.oversightboard.com/decision/fb-57spp63y/

**To read see all submitted Public Comments: https://www.oversightboard.com/news/